Unlock the Editor’s Digest at no cost
Roula Khalaf, Editor of the FT, selects her favorite tales on this weekly publication.
South Korean exporters of merchandise starting from metal and petrochemicals to textiles and cosmetics are struggling to compete with a glut of products from Chinese language rivals, as the results of overcapacity and sluggish home demand spill over into international markets.
Even Korean makers of kimchi, the fermented vegetable product broadly seen as an emblem of nationwide id, are feeling the warmth. South Korea imported extra kimchi within the first half of 2024 — nearly all of it from China — than it exported, amid intensifying competitors from Chinese language kimchi that value six occasions lower than the Korean equal.
South Korea was broadly predicted to be a winner of accelerating commerce tensions between China and the west, as US and EU tariffs and restrictions on China’s entry to next-generation vitality applied sciences drove international patrons to Korea’s semiconductor and electrical automobile industries. The worth of Korean exports has risen each month since October final yr.
However commerce specialists mentioned a lot of these good points have been due to surging demand for reminiscence chips — South Korea’s main export — and have been masking ache in different sectors, that are shedding market share to lower-cost Chinese language opponents.
“A lot of narratives about Chinese overcapacity are heavily focused on China’s trade disputes with the west, and on EVs, solar and batteries,” mentioned Yeo Han-koo, a former South Korean commerce minister now on the Peterson Institute for Worldwide Economics in Washington.
“But this is something that is affecting the whole global economy, and which is much broader than just the green industrial sector.”
In line with a survey of producing corporations launched final month by the Korea Chamber of Commerce and Business, 70 per cent of corporations mentioned they both already felt or have been anticipating injury to their enterprise on account of Chinese language exports.
A lot of that competitors is in markets resembling south-east Asia, the Center East, central Asia and Latin America, the place Chinese language exporters have turned searching for development in response to overcapacity and sluggish demand at residence in China.
The typical value of Chinese language exports globally decreased each month between January 2023 and April of this yr, falling 10.2 per cent total, in keeping with information from the Korea Worldwide Commerce Affiliation, whereas that of Korean exports fell simply 0.1 per cent over the identical interval.
“China diverting exports away from the US and Europe works like a double-edged sword for us,” mentioned Do Received-bin, a researcher at KITA. “We have more opportunities to export to the US because of China’s absence there, but China’s exports to countries like Vietnam, Saudi Arabia, Brazil and Kazakhstan have increased a lot this year, posing challenges to Korean companies in those markets.”
Korean steelmakers have suffered a very extreme blow, as rising Chinese language competitors has coincided with a slowdown within the home development sector.
Hyundai Metal reported a 78.9 per cent year-on-year fall in working revenue within the second quarter, whereas Posco’s metal division reported a decline of fifty.3 per cent and Dongkuk Metal, a fall of 23 per cent. In line with the Korean Iron and Metal Affiliation, Chinese language metal prices a mean of $863 per ton, in contrast with a value of $2,570 per ton for Korean metal.
Main Korean petrochemical corporations are additionally struggling, with some halting manufacturing, exiting joint ventures and deferring enlargement plans amid mounting losses of their core companies.
Do mentioned Korean corporations wanted to reply by “differentiating their products through quality”.
However the KCCI survey discovered that Korean producers have been additionally shedding religion of their capability to take care of superiority. Solely 26.2 per cent of corporations mentioned they’d maintained a constant technological and high quality benefit over their Chinese language opponents over the previous 5 years, and 73.3 per cent that at present get pleasure from technological parity or superiority mentioned they anticipated to be overtaken throughout the subsequent 5 years.
Korean corporations are more and more mounting a authorized fightback, stepping up anti-dumping and patent infringement complaints towards Chinese language rivals.
In line with South Korea’s business ministry, Korean corporations — led by the metal, petrochemical and battery industries — are on target this yr to register the best variety of anti-dumping circumstances towards Chinese language opponents since 2002, the yr after Beijing joined the World Commerce Group. China accounts for 10 of the 12 circumstances of leaks of essential applied sciences registered by South Korea’s Nationwide Police Company this yr.
“Until recently, Korea has been relaxed about Chinese investment despite the risk of technology leaks,” mentioned Choi Byung-il, a commerce professional and professor emeritus at Ewha Womans College. “But the country now needs more sophisticated measures for its economic security — a more active government role is needed to make it a level playing field.”
